Cogswell claimed to have been a passenger on the train that Kate Shelley stopped in Iowa in 1881 during a rain storm. Her courage saved the lives of all the passengers. Nearly twenty years after the near accident, Cogswell donated a large metal sculpture of himself atop a large drinking fountain dedicated to Kate Shelley. The statue was constructed in WASHINGTON PARK.
Cogswell had other motives in building the fountain. The statue he gave to Dubuque was one of many he had constructed around the United States. His belief was that if people had access to cool water they would not drink alcohol. He had a goal of building one drinking fountain for every one hundred saloons in the United States. His fountains could be found in New York City; Buffalo, New York; and Boston, Massachusetts. The one in Washington, D.C. is known as the "Temperance Fountain."
One story claims an explosive was attached to the statue, but the cast iron weathered the blast. In 1900 a group of vandals pulled the statue from its base. It was thought they buried it under excavations for a new sidewalk. The next day concrete was poured over the site entombing the object it was believed. All visible remains of the statue were removed in 1912.
In 2007 when renovations were made to the park, efforts were made with metal detectors to find the statue. Nothing was located leading to the thought that the vandals had thrown the sculpture into the MISSISSIPPI RIVER.